What is Nature?
Monday, November 17th, 2008The Kuzari was the king of Khazar, a city whose king and inhabitants are said to have converted to Judaism after lengthy discussion with a Jewish sage.
*******
69. The Rabbi: “I can answer that in just a few short sentences. Do you ascribe the wisdom you detect in the anatomy of an ant to the influence of a star, a galaxy or something other than God Almighty?”
70. The Kuzari: “The anatomy of an ant is nature’s doing.”
71. The Rabbi: “And what do you mean by ‘nature’?”
72. The Kuzari: “The scientists call it a kind of force. I admit, I don’t have the foggiest idea what they mean by that, but I”m sure the scientists know what they are talking about.”
73. The Rabbi: “Believe me, they don’t know any more than we do. Aristotle vaguely defined nature as the primary cause that makes things move or rest, as long as these changes are inherent — not accidental — to these things.”1
74. The Kuzari: “Aristotle seems to be saying that an object that changes inherently — in and of itself –[like a plant that grows or dies] — has a cause that makes it change. He calls that cause “nature.”
75. The Rabbi: “Aristotle drew a sharp distinction between things that move or rest accidentally [through outside influences] and things that move or rest inherently, by nature.”
76. The Kuzari: “If so, [that nature is the cause that makes things grow,] I realize that these thinkers have misled us with the definition of the word “nature.” They have us believe that nature has the power to think and act, just as God does. Why don’t we just say ‘God’ instead of ‘nature’?”
77. The Rabbi: “You are right. When we speak of ‘the wisdom of nature’ we mean the wisdom of the Creator. Still, the term ‘nature’ should not be cast aside completely; it does have some validity. The sun, moon, and stars, all have inherent powers, such as warming, cooling, providing moisture and dryness. They do these things, not because they have a will and can think on their own, but because God appointed them to perform these functions. However, the composition of all living things, their ability to reproduce, and their will can be attributed only to the All-knowing, Almighty God. You may use the term ‘nature’ to describe the functions of the sun, moon, and the planets which affect the climate of the world, as long as you don’t credit them with any intelligence. A man and woman who have a child did not actually create and form the baby. They only supplied the seed which is the raw material which is shaped by the Creator into the human form…”
*******
From “The Kuzari - Part 1″ Translated by Avraham Yaakov Finkel
*******
- “Inherent change” refers to: birth, growth, wilting, death, and decay. “Incidental change” refers to outside influences that bring about change. ↩





