Democarcy Is Not Torah
Tuesday, December 30th, 2008When Noahides express support of “Israel,” it is important to know who it is that you are supporting.
It is important because the spiritual concept of a Noahide is a soul that attaches itself to G-d’s people (as opposed to a convert who becomes one of them).
“I support Israel.” Do you mean the Israeli government? the Israel Defense Forces? the Israeli Rabbinate? The Israeli citizens?
Unfortunately, G-d has not brought us the Final Redemption yet. Hence, the Land of Israel is filled with the Children of Israel, but run by (some) people who are very anti-Torah-of-Israel.1 It’s a twisted situation of transition, and is far more complicated than this.
The Israeli government is not based on the morality of the Torah. It is based on the morality of secular Democracy (with a sprinkle of Jewish culture). Democracy is only a vessel, a garment, a body - but not a soul. It holds no inherent moral system. Rather, Democracy holds the morality with which it’s leaders and population inject it.
Hence, the Israeli Knesset’s (parliament’s) approval of Operation Cast Lead could not be more opposite from Torah values:
(IsraelNN.com) All Knesset parties except for Meretz [(very liberal party -iHN)] and the Arab parties approved the decision to support the action in Gaza. The decision stated: “It is the right of the State of Israel to defend itself just as it is the right of any nation to do so. It is the right of the citizens of Israel to live with security just as it the right of any other citizens to do so.”
First of all, all Torah thoughts aside, it is not the government’s right to defend its citizens, it is the government’s job!
Secondly, the secular Zionists did not found the State of Israel as a fulfillment of redemption from 2,000-year exile. Rather, they wanted a state “like any other nation.” They thought that this would end the phenomenon of anti-semitism. It was their solution to the “final solution.”
But G-d does not want Jews to be like any other nation! The Jews are meant to be a holy nation of priests who will share G-dliness with the entire world.
Because the secular society in Israel strives to be like “any other nation,” the hand of anti-semitism, no matter be it Kassam rockets in Israel or Al Qaeda terrorists in Mumbai, strikes a lethal reminder that we Jews are not like any other nation.
Neither should we live like any other nation, nor should we die like any other nation.
Therefore we must fight for our lives in the manner that befits G-d’s priestly people, and not in the manner of “any other nation.” That is to say, relentlessly - without fear - and with complete faith in Hashem.
- Despite this, “lev melachim v’sarim b’yad Hashem” - “The hearts of kings and ministers are in the ‘hand’ of G-d.” ↩




